Two cases, one decided earlier this year, suggest that state courts may be expanding university liability to those injured by fraternity misconduct, and the key is not location but rather the degree of control.
There has been a great deal of public criticism of Cornell University, and its president, for the university’s response to allegations of serious sexual misconduct involving Cornell students at a fraternity house.
But beyond just public condemnation, what are the legal standards governing the liability of a university for fraternity misconduct? Are those standards evolving? And how much does it depend on whether the frat house was on or off campus? Or whether the people involved were students? Or even in which state it took place?
Perhaps most importantly, how will proposed remedies – ranging from tightening regulation of fraternities to eliminating them altogether – affect universities’ legal exposure for what happens afterward?
A close examination of two contrasting appeals court rulings – one from 2018 in California, the other decided earlier this year in the state of Washington – helps answer those questions and suggests a move toward greater institutional liability. While one case does not make a trend, it does – taken together with the public outcry against Cornell – suggest that legal standards in this area may be tracking the public’s demand for greater institutional accountability.
Whether a university can be held liable for the misconduct of fraternities (or other third parties) depends on whether the university owes a “duty of care” to the individuals involved. While the decisions of one state’s highest court are not binding precedent on another’s, they are influential because they are interpreting similar, if not identical, statutes that are often based on language in a scholarly work known as the Restatement of Torts.
California
The California case involved a non-student who was injured when she fell off a platform at a party held by the chapter of Sigma Alpha Epsilon at its house on “Greek Row” near the campus of the University of Southern California. Though not on campus, the fraternity was subject to certain university rules and regulations, including limitations on party times and the use of alcohol. The university was aware of prior violations by that fraternity, and USC police had issued a warning about the party.
In the woman’s subsequent lawsuit, she claimed the university was liable for its failure to enforce the rules and shut the party down. Although she wasn’t a student, she asserted the university owed her a duty of care because it had assumed a duty to supervise behavior on and around campus and that she had relied on USC to provide a safe environment. The university contended that as a non-student at a non-USC event off campus, it had no liability for the actions of third parties.
The issue reached the California Supreme Court, where it became one of the leading precedents in this area, so the court’s analysis warrants a close look. It noted that earlier that same year (2018), it had decided a case involving the University of California known as Regents in which it had traced the evolution of university liability to third parties.
Decades ago, the court explained, the now-quaint idea that universities stood in loco parentis[1] faded and colleges came to be seen as “bystanders” to student misbehavior, even in the university’s own dormitories. In Regents, the court adopted a new rule that the university would be liable for third-party actions but only extending “to activities that are tied to the school’s curriculum but not to student behavior over which the university has no significant degree of control.” Moreover, it said, there was not an absolute duty to prevent harm, but only “a duty to act with reasonable care when aware of a foreseeable threat of violence in a curricular setting.”
The USC frat party fell outside that scope, the court found: “A college has little control over such noncurricular, off-campus activities, and it would be unrealistic for students and their guests to rely on the college for protection in those settings.” It went on to say, “The dependency and control that are characteristic of special relationships are absent in those circumstances. We conclude that USC had no special relationship with Cal. Gamma [the USC chapter] or its members so as to give rise to a duty of care owed to guests at the party.”
Nor, it said, did USC “assume a duty to protect invitees from third party conduct at fraternity parties. Again, a college has little control over such noncurricular, off-campus activities, and it would be unrealistic for students and their guests to rely on the college for protection in those settings.” It added that, given her own drug and alcohol use, and her behavior, she could not reasonably rely on university to protect her.[2]
Washington State
Earlier this year, Washington’s Supreme Court reached the opposite conclusion from California in a case involving freshman Sam Martinez’s hazing death, Martinez v. Washington State University. The 5-4 ruling emphasized it expressed no opinion on WSU’s ultimate liability, but only that the state’s law does not preclude such a finding at trial.
The court’s majority based its finding on the degree of control the university exercised through its housing agreement and other regulation of the fraternity, together with the degree to which the university benefited from the relationship, particularly in student recruitment. Indeed, the court said, WSU “could have stayed completely separate” but chose not to. The justices seemed particularly influenced by allegations that the university’s marketing concealed the less attractive aspect of fraternity life, including prior problems with underage drinking that led to creation of a Presidential Task Force on Alcohol Education, and the particularly bad history of the frat in question, which had lost chapter recognition in 2013. The court quoted the student’s father’s testimony that had he known the facts he would not have allowed his son to pledge.
The court acknowledged that a 2024 case involving WSU, Barlow v. State, held that the university did not owe a duty to protect a student from another student’s sexual assault at off-campus housing, and had limited liability to “a student’s enrollment and presence on campus or participation in university controlled activities.”
But, the court said, the university’s special relationship with Martinez’s fraternity, by virtue of its degree of control and other relationships, differentiated this case from the off-campus apartment involved in Barlow.
“WSU had the ability to require fraternities to comply with rules meant to prevent the type of accident that happened here. . . . WSU was in a position to foresee harm and to take preventative measures to protect students like Sam from the dangers posed by fraternity hazing. Not only did the university help facilitate student involvement in fraternities, but it also continued to provide guidance, support, and oversight to fraternities, giving it the power to address such dangers.”
The four dissenters, citing the California cases, supported WSU’s motion to dismiss the case against it. They said the university lacked sufficient control over the fraternity to establish a duty to the student, characterizing the relationship as more contractual than controlling and noting that the university’s Relationship Agreement with the frat “explicitly stated that WSU does not control, supervise, or direct chapter activities.”
Looking Ahead
What do these cases tell us about the direction in which the law is moving? And what are their implications for how universities should address the current debate over how to deal with fraternities?
- Trend towards greater institutional exposure: While there are only a handful of precedents, they do suggest a trend towards increasing liability for the off-campus actions of third parties such as fraternities, when the university has recognized them and exercises some degree of control or regulation, particularly when the injured party is a student and the injury occurred at a fraternity event.
- Control is the issue: The degree of the university’s control and involvement, not whether the house is on or off campus, has emerged as the crucial question.
- Was bad actor not a student? Courts may balk at extending university liability to the criminal acts of nonstudents, even when they occur at a frat party. In Meola v. Ohio State University, an Ohio court held the university not liable for a shooting by a non-student at a frat party, noting that the university had no control over the house in general or over the door on the night of the event.
- Raised public expectations: Increasing institutional accountability appears consistent with elevated public demands generated by the Cornell matter and other highly publicized fraternity incidents. Public awareness of university involvement in sexual harassment disputes via Title IX probably contributes to expectations that universities will act in cases of fraternity misconduct.
- Avoiding inflammatory facts: Even where the law makes university liability possible, it is not inevitable. Each case will turn on its facts, and universities will want to avoid facts that inflame judges and juries. Red flags include:
- Failure to enforce rules and regulations
- Reinstatement of chapters with histories of bad behavior
- Failure to disclose problems to recruits and parents
- Failure to follow through on remedial recommendations
- Beware unintended consequences: Will the response to potentially greater liability cause universities to limit their regulation of fraternities or to distance themselves entirely as some have suggested? And if so, will that just make the problem worse? The California court thought so, saying, “finding a duty in these circumstances could create a disincentive for universities to regulate alcohol use and social activities and provide security patrols, which to some degree could frustrate the policy of preventing future harm.” But that disincentive might be overcome by public demands for greater institutional accountability.
- Require insurance to limit exposure? Should universities place greater liability insurance obligations on fraternities? A writer in the Stanford Law Review in 2020 proposed stricter insurance requirements on frats to provide victims with a practical avenue for financial compensation.[3]
- Communicate carefully: The relative handful of reported opinions in this area creates uncertainty, which adds to both legal and communications risk. While universities will often want to provide reassurance regarding the robustness of their governance or recognition of Greek life, using words like “control” and related concepts may be legally risky. Communications on this subject should be carefully coordinated with legal counsel.
Disclaimer: This article was prepared by Bill Feldman and Zach Irsik of Legend Labs. Mr. Feldman is Senior Counselor to the firm and is a member of the District of Columbia Bar. The information contained in this article is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
[1] See, Peter Lake, The Rise of Duty and the Fall of In Loco Parentis and Other Protective Tort Doctrines in Higher Education Law, 64 Mo. L. Rev. (1999).
[2] Although the plaintiff’s impairment by drugs and alcohol was a relatively minor point in the court’s opinion, Jane Doe’s degree of impairment in the Cornell case, together with an unusual provision in New York law regarding prior impairment and capacity to consent, has emerged as a significant issue.
[3] Alexandra Willingham, Opening the Door, 72 Stan. L. Rev. 1717 (2020).